Should you buy the Iceman Countertop Nugget Ice Maker? Detailed review

Description

Ease of Use

Using the Iceman Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, model RJ56-D-2, feels like a breeze. The digital display is intuitive, with clear indicator lights that tell you when the water reservoir is low, the ice bin is full, or the self-cleaning process is underway. I appreciated how simple it was to set up; even connecting it to a waterline wasn’t overly complex (though professional installation is recommended). My favorite part was the top viewing window—being able to peek inside to check ice levels saved me from opening the lid unnecessarily. It’s a plug-and-play experience, which is always a win for someone like me who isn’t exactly tech-savvy.

Ice Quality & Type

The nugget ice this machine produces is nothing short of delightful. I’m a self-proclaimed ice chewer, so the soft, chewable pellets were a game-changer for me. These little nuggets are perfect for cocktails, sodas, or even as a snack on their own. The ice doesn’t clump together much, making it easy to scoop out without frustration. I’ve used similar machines in the past, but the texture and consistency here felt superior. My kids even got into the habit of sneaking a few pieces while waiting for their drinks!

Ice Production Speed

This ice maker isn’t just about quality—it’s about speed too. Within 20 minutes of turning it on, I had my first batch of ice ready to go. That’s impressive compared to the sluggish pace of my refrigerator’s built-in ice maker. However, I noticed that it takes a few cycles to build up a generous stash of ice, so planning ahead is essential if you’re hosting a party. I’ve started bagging the ice and storing it in the freezer for larger gatherings, which works well but does require some monitoring.

Noise Levels

While this machine isn’t silent, it’s considerably quieter than others I’ve encountered. The humming and occasional ice-dumping sounds are subtle enough not to disrupt conversations or TV shows in the background. I placed it on the kitchen counter, and even late-night ice production didn’t bother anyone in the house. If you’re sensitive to noise, this model might still be a good fit for you.

Features

The Iceman Countertop Nugget Ice Maker is loaded with features that make it stand out. The self-cleaning function was a lifesaver for me—I simply pressed a button, and the machine handled the rest. The 5-foot power cord gave me flexibility in where I could place it, and the bottom drain outlet made it easy to empty and clean. It even comes with a plastic scoop and removable ice basket, making the whole experience feel seamless. I do wish there was a built-in spot to store the scoop, though. As it stands, I’ve been leaving it on top of the machine, which isn’t ideal.

Durability

One thing that struck me was the stainless steel construction. Beyond its sleek, modern look, it feels sturdy and built to last. I’ve been using it daily for weeks, and it hasn’t shown any signs of wear or tear. The materials seem high-quality, and I’m confident it will hold up well over time. A few other machines I’ve used in the past felt flimsy in comparison, but this one inspires trust.

Warranty

A one-year warranty is included, which gave me some peace of mind when making the purchase. I haven’t had to use it so far, but knowing it’s there is reassuring. Chefman, the manufacturer, appears to have a good reputation for customer service, based on what I’ve read. Still, I hope I never have to test that for myself!

Advantages

• Produces soft, chewable nugget ice perfect for drinks and snacking.
• Quick ice production—ready in just 20 minutes.
• Sleek stainless steel design complements any kitchen.

Downsides

• The ice doesn’t stay cold in the basket and melts if left too long.
• Lacks a designated holder for the included scoop.
• Requires constant monitoring to transfer ice to the freezer for long-term storage.

Product Comparisons

Compared to similar countertop ice makers, this model excels in both speed and ice quality. Machines like the GE Profile Opal Nugget Ice Maker also produce chewable ice but come at a much higher price point. While the Opal boasts app connectivity and larger capacity, the Iceman offers a more budget-friendly option without compromising significantly on performance. On the other hand, cheaper models from brands like Frigidaire often lack features like self-cleaning or waterline compatibility, making the Iceman stand out as a well-rounded choice.

Cost Efficiency

For the features it offers, this ice maker delivers solid value for the price. It’s not the cheapest on the market, but the combination of quality, speed, and convenience makes it worth the investment. I’ve saved money by no longer buying bags of nugget ice from the store, and the time saved during parties is priceless. If you’re looking for an appliance that balances affordability with premium features, this one’s a great pick.

Additional information